Showing posts with label Trading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trading. Show all posts
Monday, March 1, 2010
The Problem with Commodities ETFs
Last week, Hard Assets Investor published another one of my articles. In it, I compared the correlations between several energy ETFs and the prices of commodities they are tracking. The takeaway message is that, for the most part, ETFs do a bad job tracking commodities prices. There are a few reasons for this.
The first, and primary reason why the correlation is less than perfect, is that the front-month futures contract for every commodity is constantly changing. Since most ETFs hold only the front-month contract, this means that sometime before expiration, the fund must sell its holding of one (soon to expire) contract and then purchase another (soon to be front-month) contract. There is almost always a significant discrepency between the two prices, particularly if it's a commodity that doesn't deliver every month. Take a look at the futures chains on the CME group website for crude oil, gold, and corn. As of writing, the difference between the front month and second month contract is about 40¢, $1, and 10¢, respectively. That may not seem like much, but that price difference represents a pure loss in the value of the fund with every roll that takes place. Just to prevent declines, the fund would, on average, have to be increasing in value between 1 and 5% a month. That means that, depending on the commodity and the fund, a monthly percentage increase, if not sufficiently high, may actually mean you're losing money.
The second problem with ETFs is that they create a secondary market on top of what is already a volatile market in its own right. And, while the underlying instruments are the same for both, (futures contracts) the factors driving the supply and demand may be drastically different. For example, while natural gas might be moving up on strong demand resulting from a particular weather forecast, if the primary participants are energy hedgers, no such demand would exist for UNG, the world's biggest natural gas etf. As such, UNG might theoretically follow the price of gas with something of a lag, rather than actually track the price in real time.
Don't take my word for it, take a look at this graph comparing oil price movements with the price of USO, the world's biggest crude oil ETF, over the last four years:
Now, you might be saying "those charts seem to follow each other reasonably well" but that's the problem. Reasonably well isn't good enough. An investor buying a share or shares in a commodity ETF that puportedly tracks the price of a commodity wants her investment to actually do just that, not merely track the price "reasonably well".
It's true that there are some ETFs, especially those dealing with precious metals, that eliminate the problem of the roll yield altogether simply by buying and hoarding the commodity in question and storing it in a vault somewhere; no futures contracts required. While certainly effective in mitigating the problem, this only works for a very specific subset of commodities that do not have a cliff for their usefulness. Other than those few cases, in general, the moral is that if you really, truly want exposure to commodities, don't waste your time with an ETF. As they stand, very few of them can be relied upon to achieve their goals. Though that may change in the future, for now, your best bet is get into the futures market directly.
Tuesday, January 19, 2010
Why Imposing Oil Position Limits is a Tremendous Mistake
As a follow up to my post on Friday about how the CFTC's proposed oil and gas position limits are ultimately wrongheaded, I wanted to talk a bit more about why position limits won't solve the problem, and why these regulations are ultimately bad for the markets they are supposedly trying to protect.
As I said in Friday's post, the problem is not position size, but leverage. And the reason leverage is a problem is that small market moves are amplified by virtue of the buying and selling that NECESSARILY must follow when positions are entered into via margin.
To understand this, first, consider that unlike a stock every futures contract is entered into by two individual parties. There is no corporate entity issuing these contracts to raise capital as is the case in the stock market. Further, the commodities do not necessarily have to even exist for the contract to be initiated. Today, I could "sell" you 5,000 bushels of oats to be delivered in September. Never mind that I live nowhere near an oat farm, let alone the Chicago warehouse to which those oats would be delivered. No, as an investor, I would be selling you those oats with the intention of buying the same amount of oats from someone else later to offset my position, hopefully at a lower price than the one I gave you. My bet is that the price oats will go down between now and September. Your bet is that the price of oats will go up. Thus, for every futures contract that exists, there is a bullish participant, and a bearish participant. The bullish participant (the buyer) expects the value of the underlying commodity to go up, or at the very least, to NOT go down. The bearish participant expects the price to go down, or at least to NOT go up. In every trade, someone is wrong and someone is right.
Now, back to the point at hand, by virtue of the fact that someone wins and someone loses on ANY price movement, the dramatic effects of leverage can work like a positive feedback loop. Commodities exchanges and financial institutions facilitating futures trading require that a certain amount of money be maintained in an account to maintain one's position. This is called the "maintenance margin" and adverse price movements can wipe you out, initiating a "margin call" where the exchange or brokerage requires you put up more money or else exit the position.
Let's take a concrete example with a fake commodity. Assume there are two speculators: Albert and Brian. Each of whom has $10,000 he'd like to invest in Widget futures, currently trading at $20 a box with one Widget contract equal to 500 boxes, making the total value of one Widget contract $10,000 (convenient, eh?). The exchange requires a minimum margin of $1000 per contract. Albert, the more risk averse of the two, buys exactly one contract. Brian, seeking to amplify his gains, buys ten contracts. Albert is not leveraged whatsoever, whereas Brian is as leveraged as possible. The next day, the price of Widgets falls from $20/box to $19/box. Albert is now down $500, whereas Brian is down $5000 (–$500 x 10 contracts = –$5000). Since Brian has fallen below the margin requirement of $1000 per contract, his broker tells him he must either add another $5000 to his account, or else exit his position. Having no more funds to allocate, Brian tries to sell his Widget contracts (all ten of them) to exit his position. However, because the price has gone down, many other investors are also trying to sell their Widget contracts, having received margin calls from their brokers. The flood of sell orders drives the price of widgets even lower. Eventually, some buyers enter the market at the deep discount of $18 / box, and this is the price at which Brian is forced to sell. Now, at $18 / box, Albert has lost a net of $1000, while Brian has lost every last penny. Incidentally, Albert (always patient) can wait for the price to go up, as he knows these sorts of market hiccups are to be expected. Brian, meanwhile, moves all of the rest of his money into T-Bills.
Now, what about oil? The above scenario is precisely what happened with oil futures in 2008. Take a look at this graph of oil prices from August 2007 through February 2009:
Oil was moving more or less sideways until February 2008. At which point, a perfect storm of geopolitical factors began driving oil prices up. As oil continued up, the bearish speculators (those who had sold oil) had to cover their positions as they were losing money. Some, certainly, received margin calls. Because they were leveraged they did not have the luxury to wait for prices to go back down to exit their positions. A flood of buy orders only served to drive prices higher until they reached the ludicrous peak of $140 / barrel, at which point, investors realized that was insane and began to sell crude like crazy. Those who had continued to buy oil all the way up to $140 now found themselves awash in sell orders and, because they too were incredibly leveraged, these folks were forced to cover their positions as oil went down, all the way through the public awareness of the credit crisis (how apropos) and into March of 2009, when sensibility and prudence (purely the product of fear) finally began to return to the market.
Would position limits have caused things to go any differently? Absolutely not. If anything, limiting the number of positions people or institutions can hold would have had an even worse effect by stifling the liquidity of the market. The problem is not position size, the problem is leverage. Now, admittedly, when large financial institutions take massive speculative positions in the market they somewhat amplify the problem. (Consider some hedge fund with 1000 Oil contracts all maximally leveraged suddenly getting a margin call; you now have 1000 more sell orders than you did five seconds ago.) But limiting leverage would in effect also limit position size. If your firm has $1,000,000 to deploy on oil contracts, and the margin requirements were $10,000 instead of $5000 per contract, the firm could buy only 100 contracts, rather than 200 under the lower margin. This would also give the firm much more breathing room, so to speak, when prices move against them. Margin calls would be fewer and further between for EVERYONE.
One last caveat, the margin problem is not so much with individual investors buying an oil contract here or there on margin, but with big firms buying hundreds of oil contracts on the smallest allowable margin.
Were I king of the CFTC, I'd impose a sliding margin requirement based on number of contracts. Something like, say, a 10% increase on minimum margin for each speculative position entered into past the 10th. Of course, lawmakers would rather their restrictions meet the populist demands than actually make sense from an economic point of view.
My advice? Stay the hell away from any index fund or ETF that tracks oil or gas. If these regulations go through, energy commodity funds are due for a liquidity shock, and some market maker will happily arbitrage your money right out of the fund.
Sunday, January 17, 2010
A follow up regarding my aforementioned "leash"
A friend of mine today wrote me an e-mail regarding my recent post on the importance of keeping your trades on a leash. He asked a pretty good question, which sort of made me feel stupid for not mentioning it in the post:
"So, how DO you keep your trades on a leash?"Excellent question. Here's what I do, and by no means should you take it as gospel. It's a weird little system that I've worked out over several years of trial and error. (By the way, if anyone out there has any suggestions for improving this method, I'd love to hear them.) Here goes:
- Before entering any position I determine how much money I'm going to allocate. Because of the relatively low margin, compared to a futures contract's true value, I always try to overshoot the margin requirement by a substantial amount. My target is to allocate at least enough money so that I'm operating at an effective leverage of 75% or less. The volatility of the market, in my opinion, makes being as leveraged as possible horrendously risky.
- Immediately upon entering a new position, I determine my maximum loss. For me, my personal rule, is 20%. That is to say, I refuse to lose more than 20% on any given trade. I do some math and determine at what price I'll have lost 20% of my allocated funds, and set that as a stop with my broker (a buy stop if I'm short, a sell stop if I'm long). As a personal rule, I will NEVER move this stop away from my position (that is to say a 20% loss is truly my personal maximum).
- I also determine what my exit point is; the price I want to exit this contract assuming it moves in my favor. I then set this as a limit order with my broker. (NB: I should say here that one of the best pieces of investment advice I ever received has caused me to be far more modest with my exit points than many traders would likely expect.*)
- Throughout the day, I alter my stop order if the price has moved in my favor.
- Unless I have new research to strongly suggest otherwise, I do not alter my limit price whatsoever.
Some of you may have noticed that what I'm describing regarding moving the stop order is technically a "trailing stop" and many brokerages allow you to do this automatically (the stop order moves to some percent above or below whatever the price is currently). Personally, though my brokerage allows it, I do not use this sort of automation. The reason is that, as I've discussed before, the market may make a weird hiccup out of nowhere and then go back to normal trading. Such a hiccup might, if your trailing stop was automated, move your stop up or down, then immediately stop you out at a loss before going back to whatever the price was before. However, since I don't move my limit, if that hiccup happens to trigger my limit order, I'll happily take the money, thank you very much.
*That advice was: "Don't worry about trying to be exactly right. If you're basically right most of the time, that's much better than being exactly right occasionally."
Thursday, January 14, 2010
The Importance of Keeping Your Trades on a Leash
Most people who start trading futures after having spent some time in the stock market expect the former to be like the latter. These people are usually in for a rude awakening. Intense volatility coupled with rock bottom margin requirements conflate to create a market environment not unlike a hurricane. In stocks, unless your're playing those crazy Russian IPOs with zero volume, a 5% swing might typically be a big day. In futures, a 5% price swing might mean the entirety of your life savings.
Let's take Lumber, for example. North American Softwood Lumber Futures (Random Length) are traded on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and are priced in dollars per thousand board feet, one contract is equal to one hundred and ten thousand board feet. (Fun fact, 110 thousand board feet is exactly the amount of lumber that will fit in a boxcar. It's true, some guy told me that one time.) As of this writing, the front month (January) Lumber contract istrading at ~$220 per thousand board feet. That means that the net value of one contract of North American Softwood Lumber is $24,200. And yet, if you'd like to buy or sell one of these contracts, all you need to put up is ~$1800 (give or take, depends on your broker). So, today, with less than $2000, Joe Schmo can control nearly $25,000 worth of Lumber. That's an effective margin of 92%. Now, assume Joe is long 1 lumber contract, and the price moves down 5% to ~$209/mmBF. That 5% change is equivalent to a loss of $1210. Assuming Joe only put up $1800 to buy that contract, that leaves him down a whopping 67% on his initial investment, after only a 5% change in price. And remember, that's assuming he bought only one contract. Ouch.
To make things even more difficult, most of the commodity markets are open around the clock, so prices may be climbing or falling while you're eating breakfast, at the movies, or fast asleep. Take a look at this technical chart (retrieved via optionsXpress.com) of the March Crude Oil contract over the last three days, centered on yesterday's trading session:
What the hell is that? I mean, seriously, is that a prank? Oil opened the day at about $80.50 and closed the day essentially flat at about $80.35 per barrel. There was no news about oil, no major economic indicators were published, and yet, for some reason, between the hours of 9am and 1pm Eastern time, oil fell to about $78.80 per barrel and then rose back up to $80.75. If you were long March Oil, and only put up the minimum to enter into the contract, that kind of swing could potentially result in a margin call (depending on where you entered your position) immediately before jumping up to a multi-day high. If you were short, and were looking to exit at a price below $80.00, but, say, happened to live on the West Coast, you might be just arriving at work, only to realize upon powering up your computer that you missed the nadir you were looking for.
The moral is that when you're investing with futures contracts, you can't sit back and wait to see what the market does once you take a position. You need to remain active, agile, and vigilant. You need predetermined exit points, both to stop a loss AND to realize a gain, and you can't let emotion get the best of you.
Despite what your econ professor said, this market is not rational.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
